Replying to all the comments on a Facebook post with one comment: the official way, old and new comments, and what gets an account suspended
There is no "reply to all" button on Facebook. How to reply to existing comments with a scheduled bulk-reply campaign, and to new comments with page- or post-level auto-reply by keyword and a private message — through the official API, and why personal-account apps get you suspended.
On this page 5
The short answer
Facebook itself has no "reply to all" button, and any app that does it through your personal account risks a suspension. The official route through the Pages API: a bulk-reply campaign where you pick the post and write the reply, posted under every existing comment on a schedule with spacing, and auto-reply to new comments at page or post level with keywords and a private message to the commenter. Better than "one reply for all": replies by keyword (price, size, delivery) and a private message that opens a conversation the agent continues. In our measurement of 66,118 comments, 58.5% arrived outside working hours and 57.5% were a price question.
Also asked as: «ازاي ارد على كل الكومنتات بتعليق واحد» · «كيف ارد على جميع التعليقات مرة وحدة» · «رد على كل التعليقات القديمة تلقائي» · «كيفية الرد على جميع التعليقات في الفيس بوك» · «الرد على الكومنتات القديمة بضغطة زرار» · «برنامج إدارة تعليقات السوشيال ميديا» · «can you reply to all comments on facebook» · «how to reply to all comments on facebook at once» · «how do you reply to all comments on a facebook post» · «how to reply to all comments in one place»
Three cases, three tools
| Case | Tool | How | Do not |
|---|---|---|---|
| A post with a hundred old comments and no reply | A bulk-reply campaign | Pick the post, write the reply or several variants, set the spacing, run | Run two campaigns on the same post |
| New comments arriving every minute | Page- or post-level auto-reply | A keyword rule: "price" → reply with the price + a private message | Reply to every comment with the same sentence |
| A question that deserves a conversation | A private message to the commenter | "We sent you the details privately" under the comment, and the agent continues the chat | Write the price in the comment for the competitor to see |
How to reply to all comments on Facebook: bulk reply to existing comments
- Pick the post
From Facebook tools → bulk comment reply → new campaign → the page and the post.
- Write the reply — or several variants
Two or three variants chosen in turn or at random, with an image or video if you like. One identical reply under a hundred comments is what looks automated.
- Space the timing
A start time and a gap between replies. A hundred replies in a minute get throttled by Facebook; a hundred over an hour pass.
- Read the report
How many were replied to, how many failed and why, per campaign.
Auto-reply to new comments
A rule at page level or on one post: the words that trigger it (or all comments), the public reply under the comment, and the private message to its author. The private message is what turns a comment into a customer: it opens a conversation in the unified inbox where the agent answers from your files. From comment to private message.
Browser extensions and "reply to all" apps that ask for your personal account password or run inside it. Facebook detects automated clicks from a person's account and suspends it, and the suspension can reach the page. The official API works with the page's permissions, not anyone's account. Facebook auto-reply.
What we measured in 66,118 comments: why replying by hand is not enough
On the Pages of 18 Egyptian businesses whose comments ArabyBot handles, 39,135 people wrote 66,118 comments in forty days:
| When the comment arrived (Cairo time) | Its share of the comments |
|---|---|
| 6 pm to midnight | 35.3% |
| Noon to 6 pm | 31.5% |
| 6 am to noon | 18.1% |
| Midnight to 6 am | 15.0% |
So more than half of the comments arrive while you are off work, and more than half are one question repeated. One rule on the price words answers most of them in seconds, and what needs a person is left for you. The two largest businesses hold 89% of this sample, so it describes these Pages and is not a rule for all. The full measurement: what people write under shops' posts
Frequently asked questions
Is there a "reply to all comments" button on Facebook?
No, not in the app and not in Business Suite. Apps that promise it and run through your personal account imitate human clicks, and Facebook suspends accounts that do. The only safe route is the official Pages API with your page's permissions.
What is the difference between bulk reply and auto-reply?
Bulk reply is for existing comments: you pick a post and write a reply that is posted under every comment on it, once, on a schedule with spacing. Auto-reply is for new comments: a rule on the page or a post that replies to every new comment as it arrives, by keyword if you like, with a private message to its author.
Does the same reply under a hundred comments hurt?
Yes, if it is one sentence for everyone: it looks automated, draws reports, and Facebook throttles identical replies in quick succession. Make the reply depend on the keyword (price, size, delivery), use several variants chosen at random, and keep the spacing the campaign sets.
Does the same work on Instagram?
Auto-reply to new comments and the private message work on Instagram through the official API. Bulk reply to old comments is a Facebook feature. Comment automation on both platforms.
Does replying to comments cost anything?
Nothing at Meta: comments and private messages on Facebook and Instagram carry no per-message fees. What you pay is the platform subscription.
When do most Facebook comments arrive?
In our measurement of 66,118 comments under the posts of 18 Egyptian businesses, 35.3% arrived between 6 pm and midnight Cairo time, and 15% between midnight and 6 am; so more than half of them (58.5%) arrive before 9 am or after 6 pm. That is why replying during working hours is not enough.
Read next
Try the agent before you pay anything
The agent that will answer your customers is the one answering you now: ask it from the chat button here or on WhatsApp. Your account is free with no credit card, and the free trial on your own number or page is activated after you contact our team on customer-service WhatsApp.